Medicare Opt-Out Screening in Behavioral Health: The Two-Year Renewal and the Prescriber You Cannot Bill For

, ,
Circa Behavioral Healthcare Solutions

A psychiatrist joins your program from a cash-pay private practice. Credentialing pulls the CV, the DEA registration, the state license and the board certification. Everything is clean. The CMS-855I goes in, and weeks later the Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC) sends it back: the practitioner has an active Medicare opt-out on file. Meanwhile your IOP has been scheduling Medicare patients onto that prescriber’s panel since the start date.

This is one of the quieter enrollment failures in behavioral health. Here is what an opt-out is, why it blocks your program from billing, and the file that catches it before the first claim.

The Opt-Out Rule in One Paragraph

A Medicare opt-out is a formal election, filed by an eligible practitioner through an affidavit to their Medicare Administrative Contractor, to treat Medicare beneficiaries only under private contracts and to stop billing Medicare entirely. Under the current rule, an opt-out lasts two years and renews automatically for another two-year period unless the practitioner cancels it in writing at least 30 days before the next two-year period begins. While the opt-out is in effect, no one can bill Medicare for that practitioner’s services, including a behavioral health program that employs them, and Medicare Advantage plans generally cannot pay for those services either, apart from narrow emergency and urgent care exceptions. The governing guidance is in Chapter 15 of the CMS Medicare Benefit Policy Manual.

Why Opt-Outs Surprise Behavioral Health Programs

Opt-outs are concentrated in exactly the specialty behavioral health programs recruit most aggressively. Psychiatrists account for a disproportionate share of Medicare opt-outs, because cash-pay outpatient psychiatry is a viable business model in a way that cash-pay cardiology is not. When a program recruits from that pool, the opt-out can come with the hire.

The mechanics are where it goes wrong:

  • Automatic renewal: Because the opt-out rolls over every two years without any action, a practitioner who filed an affidavit years ago and forgot about it is still opted out today.
  • Not enrolled is not the same as eligible to enroll: A PECOS search showing no active billing enrollment looks like a blank slate, but an opted-out practitioner cannot enroll to bill Medicare until the opt-out ends or is properly canceled.
  • Reassignment cannot fix it: The program cannot bill Medicare through its group enrollment for services an opted-out practitioner furnishes, so there is no workaround through the group NPI.
  • Supervision does not launder it: An opted-out practitioner cannot be the billing practitioner for incident-to services, so the therapist or nurse working under them does not create a billable Medicare claim either.
  • Medicare Advantage follows Medicare: Credentialing teams sometimes assume an MA plan contract stands apart from the Medicare opt-out. In general it does not, and MA plans are generally barred from paying opted-out practitioners outside emergency and urgent care.

What We See When the Opt-Out Is Found Late

In practice, the opt-out is rarely caught at hire. It is caught in one of three places, and each is more expensive than the last.

The first is the enrollment rejection. The 855I or the reassignment comes back, credentialing reads the letter, and someone realizes the prescriber has been seeing Medicare patients for several weeks. Those visits cannot be billed to Medicare, and because the beneficiaries never signed a private contract with the practitioner, they generally cannot be billed privately either.

The second is the claim rejection. If the program billed under the group and listed the opted-out practitioner as rendering, the claims reject. Billing staff often treat these as routine enrollment edits and resubmit, burning another cycle.

The third, and the one a compliance officer should care most about, is the claim that pays. If a claim was paid for an opted-out practitioner’s services because of a data mismatch or a supervising-practitioner substitution, that is a potential overpayment. It has to be investigated and, if confirmed, reported and returned under the Medicare 60-day overpayment rule, with the investigation documented from the day the problem surfaced.

The inconvenient truth is that most credentialing checklists in behavioral health were built around commercial payers and state Medicaid. They check CAQH, the license, the DEA registration and the OIG exclusion list. The Medicare opt-out list is missing from most of the checklists we review, because for years many programs billed Medicare for very little. That changed when Medicare began covering intensive outpatient program services and enrolling marriage and family therapists and mental health counselors in 2024, and many checklists have not caught up.

What an Opt-Out Does and Does Not Block

An opt-out blocks Medicare payment for services the opted-out practitioner personally furnishes, and it blocks billing those services through the program. It does not, by itself, prevent the practitioner from working at your program, treating commercial, Medicaid or self-pay patients, or holding a DEA registration. Medicaid enrollment is separate and governed by your state, so confirm the state rule rather than assuming either way.

CMS also allows opted-out practitioners to order and certify certain items and services for Medicare beneficiaries, such as laboratory tests, when they are properly on file. For a program that sends urine drug testing to an outside lab, that distinction matters: the lab claim may still process with an opted-out ordering practitioner even though the visit itself cannot be billed. Confirm the current ordering and certifying rules with your MAC before relying on this.

Build the Opt-Out File Today

Step one: pull the public opt-out data. CMS publishes the Opt Out Affidavits dataset on data.cms.gov, listing practitioners with active opt-outs along with their NPI, specialty, and opt-out effective and end dates. Save it with the download date in the filename.

Step two: match it against your roster. Export every NPI on your clinical roster: psychiatrists, psychiatric nurse practitioners, physician assistants, psychologists, clinical social workers, marriage and family therapists and mental health counselors. Match by NPI, not by name.

Step three: document every hit and every clean result. For each match, record the opt-out effective date, the end date and whether the practitioner intends to cancel before the next renewal. For each non-match, record that the check was run and on what date.

Step four: add the check to onboarding and to your monthly cycle. The opt-out check belongs on the same pre-hire checklist as the OIG exclusion check, and in the same monthly screening run. Practitioners can opt out while they work for you.

Step five: write the scheduling rule. If a practitioner is opted out, intake and scheduling must not place Medicare or Medicare Advantage patients on that practitioner’s panel. Add an EHR flag and test it once.

Step six: diary the cancellation deadline. If a newly hired practitioner wants to cancel their opt-out so they can enroll through your program, the written cancellation must reach their MAC at least 30 days before the next two-year period starts. Put that date on the compliance calendar the day you learn it, and keep the cancellation and the MAC’s acknowledgment in the credentialing file.

Policy Language to Check

Open your credentialing policy and search it for the word “opt.” If the only result is “optional,” the policy has a gap. At minimum, it should state that Medicare opt-out status is verified at hire and monthly against the CMS data, who performs the check, where the evidence is stored, and what scheduling and billing restrictions apply when a practitioner is opted out.

Your compliance program should also link this policy to your overpayment procedure, so that an opt-out discovered after claims were paid triggers an investigation the same day, with the start date documented. The HHS Office of Inspector General exclusion program is a useful model for structuring screening evidence, even though opt-out and exclusion are different things: one is a voluntary election, the other a sanction.

Where to Read the Rule Yourself

Do not rely on a blog post, including this one, for the precise mechanics of your situation. The operative sources are the CMS Medicare Benefit Policy Manual, Chapter 15, which sets out the opt-out, private contract and affidavit requirements, and the CMS Opt Out Affidavits dataset, which is what you screen against. This article is operational guidance, not legal advice. When the facts are unusual, such as a practitioner who wants to end a first-time opt-out early, confirm the current rule with your MAC or counsel.

Where Circa Behavioral Fits

Medicare opt-out screening is a small check with a large downside. Circa Behavioral helps behavioral health operators build credentialing and screening files that hold up to payer audits and accreditation surveys, through our compliance services and ongoing fractional compliance officer support.

If you are adding Medicare services or onboarding prescribers from private practice, call us at (888) 458-6619 to review your credentialing checklist before the next enrollment goes in. If you are preparing for accreditation at the same time, our licensing and accreditation team can align the credentialing file with what surveyors sample. Questions about a specific prescriber’s status? Reach us at (888) 458-6619.