Let's talk about your program
Book a Consultation

About Us

Our Story Circa Behavioral Healthcare Solutions was formed when a group of like-minded professionals decided to transform the behavioral healthcare industry.

Home » Blog » Medicare CMHC Certification: The 40 Percent Non-Medicare Rule and the Five-Month Cost Report Clock

Helping Organizations Become More Effective

Circa Behavioral Healthcare Solutions improves the industry’s effectiveness through leadership, teamwork, and systems. 

It aims to democratize effective behavioral health treatment while remaining hungry, humble, and smart.  Its leaders remain forever close (“Circa”) to their higher purpose which is fueled by a relentless drive to help and protect the vulnerable population in need of services.  Its brand promise is to always elevate clients’ abilities to deliver services.  Circa Behavioral does this by providing quality, team-driven, professional services to behavioral healthcare providers.

OUR MISSION

To improve the effectiveness of behavioral health treatment through leadership, teamwork, and systems.

OUR VISION

Circa Behavioral’s vision is to democratize effective behavioral health treatment.

Our Values

Hungry

We aim to deliver more use value than cash value.

Humble

We do everything in gratitude.

Smart

We chose creativity over competition.

Our Team

Meet the People Behind Circa

Experienced professionals providing compliance leadership, operational guidance, and practical support for behavioral healthcare organizations.

Most community mental health centers treat their Medicare certification as something settled at enrollment. It is not. Two obligations run underneath it for as long as the center bills Medicare: the 40 percent non-Medicare service requirement written into the federal definition of a CMHC, and the annual Medicare cost report. Neither one shows up on a daily census sheet, and both tend to surface only when a contractor, a site visitor or a revalidation reviewer asks for the numbers. This post explains what each requires in operational terms, where centers get caught, and what to pull this week so you are not reconstructing a year of data under a deadline.

Nothing here is legal advice. It is operational guidance for owners, administrators and compliance officers. Confirm how the rules apply to your organization with your Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC) and counsel.

What the 40 Percent Rule Actually Says

Under Medicare’s definition of a community mental health center at 42 CFR 410.2, a CMHC must provide at least 40 percent of its items and services to individuals who are not eligible for Medicare benefits. The requirement has applied since January 1, 2014, and it is part of the definition itself, not a billing guideline, so a center that falls below 40 percent no longer meets what Medicare means by a CMHC. That is why the number belongs in the compliance file of every Medicare-certified CMHC, checked on a schedule rather than assumed.

You can read the definition directly in the Electronic Code of Federal Regulations at 42 CFR 410.2, and CMS summarizes the certification framework on its Community Mental Health Centers certification page. The same definition also requires the center to provide a set of core community mental health services and to meet applicable state licensing or certification requirements, so the 40 percent figure sits alongside obligations your state licensure file already covers.

Two details in that wording matter more than operators expect. First, the measure is items and services, not patients. A center can serve mostly non-Medicare individuals by headcount and still drift toward the line if its Medicare patients are in partial hospitalization, which generates a high volume of services per person. Second, the rule asks about eligibility for Medicare, not who paid the claim. A Medicare-eligible client whose services were billed to a Medicare Advantage plan, a secondary payer or self-pay is still a Medicare-eligible individual for this purpose. Ask your MAC how it expects that population to be treated in your calculation before you finalize a method.

Why Centers Drift Toward the Line

The centers that get into trouble on this rule rarely set out to serve only Medicare beneficiaries. They drift. The causes are predictable enough to name:

The inconvenient truth is that most EHRs cannot produce this figure out of the box. The report that looks right, usually a payer-mix summary, answers a different question. Building the calculation once, documenting the method, and rerunning it the same way every quarter is the actual work.

The Medicare Cost Report: The Five-Month Clock

A Medicare-certified CMHC files an annual cost report with its MAC. Under the cost reporting rules at 42 CFR 413.24, a cost report is generally due on or before the last day of the fifth month after the close of the cost reporting period. For a center on a calendar fiscal year, that means a cost report for the year ending December 31 is due by May 31. Late or missing cost reports can lead the MAC to suspend or withhold Medicare payments until the report is received, which is a cash-flow problem long before it is a compliance finding.

Cost reports feed the data CMS uses in setting partial hospitalization payment under the outpatient prospective payment system, which CMS describes on its Hospital Outpatient PPS page.

Where the cost report process breaks down in practice:

Where the Two Obligations Meet

The 40 percent calculation and the cost report draw on the same underlying data: service counts by individual, by program and by period. Centers that keep those counts clean during the year handle both obligations with far less effort. Centers that do not end up reconciling twice, once for the cost report and once when someone asks about the ratio, often with figures that do not quite match. A mismatch between the service volume in your cost report and the volume you used to support the 40 percent figure is the kind of inconsistency that prompts follow-up questions.

Revalidation and site visits add pressure. When CMS or its contractor reviews a CMHC’s enrollment, the reviewer is checking that the organization still meets the definition it enrolled under. Having the ratio documented, with the method written down and the source reports saved, turns that review into a document request rather than an investigation. If your enrollment data is also out of date, see our compliance services overview for how we approach enrollment maintenance alongside certification.

What to Do This Week

These steps fit in a single working session for most centers:

  1. Pull a 12-month service report listing every billable item or service with the date, program and client identifier. Do not use the payer-mix summary.
  2. Flag Medicare eligibility for each client from your eligibility verification records, not from the payer billed. Note anyone with Medicare Advantage, Medicare as secondary or Medicare eligibility with another payer.
  3. Calculate the share of items and services delivered to individuals not eligible for Medicare. Write down the method, including how you treated each edge case, and save the source report with the date.
  4. Diary the next check for the first week of the next quarter, and name the person responsible.
  5. Put the cost report due date on the calendar now: count five months from your fiscal year-end, then set an internal deadline 45 days earlier for the statistics package.
  6. Confirm who owns MAC correspondence for the cost report and that the address on file with the contractor is monitored.

If the calculation comes out close to 40 percent, do not wait for the next quarter. Look at program mix, referral sources and planned service changes now, and talk to counsel before making decisions that affect access to care.

Building This Into a Compliance Calendar

Both obligations belong on the same compliance calendar as license renewals, accreditation reports and revalidation dates. The pattern that works is simple: a quarterly 40 percent check with a saved worksheet, a monthly cost report statistics capture, and an annual review of both methods before the fiscal year closes. Centers opening a new site or adding a program should run the 40 percent projection before launch, not after. Our guide on how to open a mental health center covers where Medicare certification fits in the startup sequence, and our licensing and accreditation team can align state licensure, accreditation and Medicare certification into one tracked timeline.

If you would like a second set of eyes on your 40 percent method or your cost report timeline, call us at (888) 458-6619. We work with CMHC operators to set up calculations that hold up when a contractor asks for them.

Key Takeaways

Questions about your CMHC’s certification file? Reach the Circa Behavioral team at (888) 458-6619.

Skip to content